Each score is that agency's best position. Needs and cities can differ, so scores do not rank these agencies against each other.
Price
From $5,000 per month, monthly retainer
published by the agency
From $500 per month, monthly retainer
published by the agency
Clients
4.9/5, 74 reviews (stronger value in this row)
Google
Good fit when
Software Pro Digital
Your business matches the client types on file (small businesses, enterprises, healthcares) and the industries on file (healthcare, construction, home services).
LinkGraph
Your business matches the client types on file (mid-market companies, B2B companies, SaaS companies) and the industries on file (b2b, saas, ecommerce).
Advernation
Your business matches the client types on file (local businesses, small businesses) and the industries on file (legal, local business).
Look elsewhere if
Software Pro Digital
Read the criticism first: "Errors, damage, and missed deadlines" (1 of 74 reviews read).
LinkGraph
Very small local businesses needing only lightweight local SEO.
Advernation
You need the setup fee in writing before you commit: it is not published.
Main risk
Software Pro Digital
6 of 35 documented work examples come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.
LinkGraph
2 of 32 documented work examples come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.
Advernation
None of the 29 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.
Not published
Software Pro Digital
minimum monthly budget, project minimum, hourly rate, typical range, setup fee, team size
LinkGraph
project minimum, setup fee
Advernation
project minimum, hourly rate, typical range, setup fee, team size
Same for all: Works: HQ in New York; Independent: none, minus 3 in the score
Tinted: the highest score or rating, the lowest price, the most cases in that row. Not a recommendation.