Each score is that agency's best position. Needs and cities can differ, so scores do not rank these agencies against each other.
Clients
4.4/5, 15 reviews (stronger value in this row)
Google
Good fit when
Blue Digital Media
Your business matches the client types on file (ecommerce brands, SaaS companies, healthcares) and the industries on file (saas, fintech, healthcare).
Codal
Your business matches the client types on file (enterprises) and the industries on file (healthcare, manufacturing, financial services).
Thinking Cat Content & Creative
Your business matches the client types on file (SaaS companies, ecommerce brands, small businesses) and the industries on file (ecommerce, saas, small business).
Look elsewhere if
Blue Digital Media
You need a published price before the first call: nothing is disclosed.
Codal
Read the criticism first: "Allegation of fake reviews" (1 of 15 reviews read).
Thinking Cat Content & Creative
You need a published price before the first call: nothing is disclosed.
Main risk
Blue Digital Media
None of the 5 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.
Codal
4 of 22 documented work examples come from independent sources; the rest are the agency's own account or sources it controls.
Thinking Cat Content & Creative
None of the 5 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.
Same for all: Works: HQ in Chicago; Price: not disclosed; Independent: none, minus 3 in the score; Not published: minimum monthly budget, project minimum, hourly rate, typical range, minimum term, setup fee, founding year, team size
Tinted: the highest score or rating, the lowest price, the most cases in that row. Not a recommendation.