What the evidence shows in New York
We reviewed 166 SEO agencies in New York. Across 16 buyer needs they hold 547 ranked places, every one of them resting on work we can point to: a case study, a portfolio entry or a client review; 31 of those places are documented by someone other than the agency itself. 13 of 16 rankings hold enough documented evidence to be offered to search engines (Local SEO, Small Business, B2B SaaS SEO, Ecommerce SEO and 9 more).
International SEO, SEO Audit and SEO Recovery repeat other rankings and stay out of search until the lists differ.
Agencies documented for more than one need
These New York agencies hold a top-three place in several rankings at once. Each ranking counts only the claims that match its own rubric, and every one of them is shown on the page it belongs to.
- NoGood: Technical SEO, AI search visibility, SEO for Startups, SEO for Lead Generation
- Power Digital: Ecommerce SEO, SEO Consulting, SEO for Marketplaces
- SEO Image: SEO Audit, SEO Consulting, SEO for High-Ticket Services
- Amsive: Ecommerce SEO, SEO Recovery
- Avenue Z: Enterprise SEO, AI search visibility
- Coalition Technologies: SEO Audit, SEO Recovery
- iPullRank: Enterprise SEO, SEO for Marketplaces
- Karpi Studio: B2B SaaS SEO, Enterprise SEO
- LinkGraph: Technical SEO, SEO for Startups
- Lounge Lizard: Content-led SEO, International SEO
- Main Street ROI: Small Business, Content-led SEO
- MeanPug: Content-led SEO, SEO for High-Ticket Services
- Mimvi SEO: B2B SaaS SEO, SEO for Lead Generation
- Veza Digital: SEO for Startups, SEO for Marketplaces
How a place in these rankings is earned
- A need page that still has fewer than ten ranked agencies after that is filled from the city's own agencies whose sources say they offer the need but document no project for it yet. They always stand below every agency with documented work, are labelled "Offers this service; no documented project on file yet", carry lower confidence, and do not count toward the threshold that opens a page to search engines.
- For an intent page, at least one claim on file supports the intent under the page's rubric, and at least one of those claims has a source address outside Vendar's own profile fields; the agency's own site counts. Our own service listings and profile tags describe the intent but document nothing, so they add weight to a vendor that already has outside evidence and never earn a rank on their own. Vendors without outside evidence appear below the ranking, unranked, never padded into it.
- Rank order is the score, highest first. Ties break on evidence points, then on the number of third-party claims, then alphabetically.
- Every ranked position explains itself from its score components and cites the claims behind them, with their sources.
The full method, including the weights and what closes a page, is published on the scoring page.
New York questions this page answers
- How many New York SEO agencies are ranked here?
- 166 SEO agencies in New York are under review. They hold 547 ranked places across 16 buyer needs, and 30 agencies appear in a top three. An agency is ranked for a need only when a claim on file documents work it did for that need.
- Why are some New York rankings missing from search results?
- An intent page is offered to search engines when its ranked list has at least five evidence-backed vendors (three when the city has fewer than twenty vendors for the service). Only agencies from the city itself (headquarters or a listed service region) with documented work count toward it: agencies filled in from other cities and agencies that only offer the need do not. A page whose list rests mostly on agencies from other cities (fewer local agencies with documented work than that threshold, or local agencies under half of the list) is titled “agencies serving” the city instead of “best agencies in” it and says in its first line how many are local and where the rest serve it from; below the threshold it stays on the city page and in its feed and is kept out of search engines until enough local agencies document the work; otherwise the same national list would stand behind six city pages. Below the threshold even with outside agencies the page stays published with noindex, keeps its URL, links and feed, and is left out of the city page's list of rankings. A page whose top ten repeats 70% or more of another need's top ten in the same city, or has the same top three, also stays noindex while the stronger of the two is offered; it opens when the lists differ. The same holds across cities: of the pages for one need whose top tens share 70% or more, only the one with the most local agencies is offered to search engines. In New York that applies to 3 of 16 needs, International SEO, SEO Audit and SEO Recovery.
- How current is the evidence?
- 67 of 547 ranked places were re-verified within the last 90 days. The newest verification on this page is dated 2026-11-06. Every claim behind a rank links to the source it came from, so any date here can be checked.
- Do agencies pay to appear in these New York rankings?
- Paid visibility never changes the order of a listing.