{"schema_version":"vendar.ai.vendor-summary.v1","object_type":"vendor_decision_summary","canonical_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/circle-marketing","machine_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/ai/vendors/circle-marketing","last_updated_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z","vendor":{"slug":"circle-marketing","name":"Circle Marketing","website":"https://circlemarketing.com/","one_line":"SEO","company_type":"agency","headquarters_location":"Los Angeles, CA, USA","service_regions":["Los Angeles","CA","USA"],"primary_services":["SEO"],"services_in_evidence":[{"service":"Social media","work_claims":10},{"service":"Email marketing","work_claims":5},{"service":"SEO","work_claims":4},{"service":"Web design","work_claims":4},{"service":"PPC","work_claims":2},{"service":"Local SEO","work_claims":1}],"services_in_evidence_note":"Each of the 28 work examples on file counted once per service it names; one example can name several services, so the counts can add up to more than 28."},"decision":{"verdict":{"label":"Ranked","summary":"Admitted to a ranking on documented work, outside the top three for every question it appears in. None of its 28 work examples comes from an independent source.","note":"Lower profile confidence; the profile is not verified by Pruvado.","missing_for_recommended":[]},"score_out_of_100":31,"confidence":{"label":"Lower confidence","score":0.62,"capped_reason":"Rated from the evidence on file (sources, independence, confirmed quotes), not by an editor.","source":"evidence","scope":"profile","score_note":null},"best_for":["Your business matches the client types on file (small businesses, entertainments) and the industries on file (small business).","You need what reviewers hired it for: Website and search engine visibility (2 of 7 mentions); Marketing support (1)."],"not_for":["You need a published price before the first call: nothing is disclosed."],"risks":["None of the 28 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","4 of 5 results with a number do not say what year they were measured.","Several commercial terms are not published."],"open_questions":["Ask for the hourly rate, minimum term, setup fee: not published.","Ask for two client references you can call: no independent case of Small Business work on file.","Ask which case is closest to your business and what the measured result was: no proof on file carries a number."],"not_published":["minimum monthly budget","project minimum","hourly rate","typical range","minimum term","setup fee","founding year","team size"],"claim_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/circle-marketing/claim","claim_note":"Agencies can state commercial terms here; published fields are labelled agency_stated.","score_basis":"Score of its best position: #10 Small Business, Los Angeles","profile_scores":{"version":"2026.11-profile-scores","completeness":{"data_completeness_pct":57,"label":"Data completeness, separate from the ranking score","parts":[{"key":"identity","label":"Who the company is: website, headquarters, founding year, team size, logo, regions served","points":12,"max":20,"detail":"founding year, team size"},{"key":"fit","label":"Fit: services, industries, client types","points":15,"max":15,"detail":"complete"},{"key":"commercial","label":"Commercial terms: model, entry price, hourly rate, minimum term, setup fee","points":0,"max":20,"detail":"model, entry price, hourly rate, minimum term, setup fee"},{"key":"work","label":"Documented work: cases naming a client and a result (target 5) and work examples overall (target 10)","points":30,"max":30,"detail":"7 cases with a named client and a result, 28 work claims"},{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation: rating and review count on two or more platforms, each with 10 or more reviews","points":0,"max":15,"detail":"0 platforms with a rating and 10 or more reviews; Google: too few reviews to count"}]},"trust":{"trust_score_out_of_100":69,"label":"Trust score, separate from the ranking score","parts":[{"key":"independence","label":"Who is speaking: independent sources among work examples (full marks at 40%)","points":0,"max":30,"detail":"0 of 28 work claims are independent"},{"key":"checked","label":"Checked against the source page: confirmed, or half for partly confirmed","points":24,"max":25,"detail":"28 confirmed, 0 partly, of 29 with a source"},{"key":"quoted_numbers","label":"Numbers backed by a verbatim quote from the source","points":20,"max":20,"detail":"5 of 5"},{"key":"fresh","label":"Seen within the last 365 days","points":14,"max":15,"detail":"28 of 29"},{"key":"not_contradicted","label":"Not contradicted: claims their source no longer supports","points":10,"max":10,"detail":"0 not supported by their page"}]}},"fit_source":{"best_for":"derived","not_for":"derived"}},"pricing":{"display":null,"model":null,"minimum_monthly_budget_usd":null,"minimum_project_size_usd":null,"pricing_range_min_usd":null,"pricing_range_max_usd":null,"hourly_rate_range":null,"public_summary":null,"secondary_options":[],"pricing_known":false,"display_basis":null,"setup_fee_usd":null,"contract_min_months":null,"engagement_models":[],"engagement_models_labels":[],"model_label":null,"minimum_project_note":null,"band_note":"The Small Business band tops out at $4,000/month; this vendor does not publish a monthly floor.","status":"unknown","not_disclosed":["minimum monthly budget","project minimum","hourly rate","typical range","minimum term","setup fee"],"agency_stated_fields":[],"published_on_site_on":null,"packages":[],"published_sources":[],"earlier_values":[]},"evidence":{"posture":{"label":"thin","summary":"No independent source documents this vendor's work; treat it as a candidate only."},"independent_validation_scope":"independent_context","independent_validation_label":"Independent context found","independence_statement":"None of the 28 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","source_counts":{"definition":"Each claim on file counted once by who wrote it. Only 'independent' counts as outside proof.","total":29,"by_speaker":{"independent":1,"affiliated":0,"vendor_controlled":0,"vendor":28},"work_claims":28,"independent_work_claims":0,"independent_work_share":0,"unique_urls":15,"scope":"whole_ledger","scope_note":"Counted over every claim in the ledger (claims_on_file), not over the claims array, which lists at most 20."},"claims":[{"id":"c_b49ab7be27d713c6","claim":"The EVgo program ran for 2 months and was repeated as a “last chance” promotion a few quarters later.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"EVgo","result_period":"2 months, then repeated a few quarters later","measured_result":true,"quote":"The program ran 2 months, then repeated as a “last chance” promotion a few quarters later.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/evgo-bmw-i3","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:53.797Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_8f6d543cdaa09df4","claim":"Over the following years, Mobile Growth Fellowship grew into a global event and media organization with a podcast generating thousands of unique listens, a newsletter with over 20,000 subscribers, and thousands of unique attendees at its globally produced two-day annual events.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Mobile Growth Fellowship","result_period":"Over the following years","measured_result":true,"quote":"Over the following years, attendance and scope have grown into a global event and media organization which now has a podcast with thousands of unique listens, a newsletter with over 20,000 subscribers, and thousands of unique attendees to their globally produced 2-day annual events.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/mobile-growth-fellowship","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:18.478Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_998412362325fbde","claim":"Circle Marketing provided Ray Lozano with SEO, email marketing, social media marketing, and ongoing marketing consultation. The page reports that his site appeared on the first page of search engines for many targeted keywords, with a monthly retainer relationship.","claim_type":"case_study","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Ray Lozano","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Ray can now be found on the first page of search engines for many of his targeted keywords, and his business has growth since working with Circle Marketing. We have a monthly retainer relationship with Mr. Lozano, and have also seen major improvements in our Email Marketing and Social Media Marketing executions as well.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/ray-lozano","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:37.296Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_385e5c01a9998c09","claim":"Circle Marketing provided Krav Maga Alliance and Alliance Culver City with a monthly full-service marketing retainer covering website design and development, video marketing, advertising, social media, email marketing, local SEO, directory management, photo shoots, and publicity.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["local-seo","by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Krav Maga Alliance","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"With a monthly full-service marketing retainer, Circle Marketing is able to help the Krav Maga Alliance and Alliance Culver City with their monthly marketing requirements of Website Design & Development , Video Marketing (Commercials, Training Videos, Video Blogs), Advertising (Google Ads, Facebook Ads), Social Media Marketing (Content Creation and Management), and other Small Business Marketing needs such as Email Marketing, Local SEO & Directory Management , Photo Shoots, and Publicity, just to name a few more.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/alliance-krav-maga","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:10.529Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_047eac5f675dbfd7","claim":"Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social media followers tripling, and traffic increasing in volume and quality. The page does not state when these results occurred.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["marketplaces","by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Krav Maga Alliance","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Since working with the Krav Maga Alliance and a few of their affiliate schools, we have seen overall increases in traffic, conversions, Search Engine Optimization listings, and of course overall awareness of the international organization as well as the local schools. AdWords Click-Through rates increased, Social Media followers have tripled, and traffic has steadily increased in both volume and quality.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/alliance-krav-maga","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:10.530Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_fd88787739e8ad1f","claim":"Rozana said her company sought marketing and social media direction and that Circle Marketing’s online course gave her resources and tools she could not otherwise access.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["small-business"],"client_name":"ROZANA, Blue Veil Events and Public Relations","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"“Action, innovation, and professional service with a personal touch. My company was looking\n\nfor much-needed marketing and social media direction. I took Circle Marketing’s online course,\n\nwhere I gained a significant amount of resources and tools I could not have access to otherwise.\n\nThe instructors are not only professional, but passionate and committed to their clients’ needs.”, ROZANA, Blue Veil Events and Public Relations","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/small-business-marketing-course","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:24.803Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_23a74aae2a846a66","claim":"For EVgo’s BMW i3 ChargeNow Program promotion, Circle Marketing created targeted advertising campaigns on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, using custom audiences, lead generation lists, lookalike audiences, and interest targeting.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["lead-generation"],"client_name":"EVgo","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Circle Marketing created targeted advertising campaigns on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. The targets were be generated from a few different Custom Audiences, lead generation lists, and lookalike audiences as well as interest targeting.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/evgo-bmw-i3","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:53.796Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_0ca4745235e8f66a","claim":"Circle Marketing created an optimized, mobile-compatible website for Veterinary Medical Center that lets prospective patients and clients submit forms online, participate in a monthly photo contest, and access patient account portals. The page also reports increased local brand awareness from the Pet Fair and describes video marketing and ongoing social media design support.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"Veterinary Medical Center","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Veterinary Medical Center now have an optimized, mobile-compatible website which allows new patients and clients to fill out forms (and submit them) online, as well as accept submissions for their monthly photo contest, and link through to portals for patients’ account maintenance. The Pet Fair was a large success, increasing brand awareness in the local community. VMC’s social media has been growing in numbers as VMC have dedicated an employee to manage their social networks and use Circle Marketing-provided designs and design direction on a monthly basis in addition to other 3rd Party post materials. The marketing videos allow the personable and highly-talented doctors to be seen to prospective clients and help spread knowledge about not only VMC, but pet care as well.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/veterinary-medical-center-studio-city-ca","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:21.043Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_a428651b34b3e053","claim":"Moggy Foggy reports that its social media fan base grew by 15x with Circle Marketing’s efforts.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Moggy Foggy","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Our social media fan base grew by 15x fold! If you're looking for a team that'll show as much passion for your business as you, call Circle Marketing!","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:22.255Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_41c181c52ada911d","claim":"A testimonial from a client identified as Ray L. says their website ranked #1 on Google and revenue increased 38.5%.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Prevention Plus","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"\"My website is ranked #1 on Google, and revenue has increased 38.5%!\"\nRay L.\nPrevention Plus","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:22.267Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_04321d08e119c960","claim":"Yoga Sol Studio reports steadily increasing revenue each month, up 92%, and an email list of over two thousand after working with Circle Marketing from pre-launch.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Yoga Sol Studio","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"\"Working with Circle Marketing from pre-launch, we have steadily increased revenue each month (up 92%), and have grown an email list over two thousand.\"\nRozanne E.\nYoga Sol Studio","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:22.269Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_bf0a4dd7eec799af","claim":"Circle Marketing provided Ray Lozano with marketing services, and he reported that his website ranked #1 on search engines and revenue increased 38.5%.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Ray Lozano","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"\"I know very little about marketing. I just want to do my work, and have people find me. Circle Marketing has done such an amazing job, I keep them on retainer. My website is ranked #1 on search engines, and costumers locate me easily. I keep detailed records of my books, and revenue has increased 38.5%!\"","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/ray-lozano","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:37.291Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_92a821f8196c2020","claim":"Circle Marketing worked with Shade 55 on its website, social media, email marketing, and marketing collateral. The company helped grow Shade 55's Facebook Likes by over 250%, established a strategy for rewarding email-list sign-ups, and created a Summer 2013 Look Book that was presented to a major retail chain where Shade 55 is now sold nationally.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Shade 55","result_period":"Summer 2013","measured_result":false,"quote":"Since taking over the Facebook page, we helped grow the Shade 55 Likes by over 250%, established a strategy for rewarding customers who signed up for the growing eMail list, and helped establish a solid blogging history for better SEO and eventual direct sales. Circle Marketing designed, photographed, and created the Shade 55 Summer 2013 Look Book which was presented to a major retail chain, which Shade 55 is now being sold in nationally.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/shade-55","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:48.518Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_1ee9718707a42a3f","claim":"Circle Marketing ran a social media advertising campaign for EVgo that generated thousands of likes and sign-ups for its ChargeNow Program.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"EVgo","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"While EVgo has since split from it’s NRG parent company, the Circle Marketing-lead social media advertising campaign generated thousands of likes and sign-ups for the ChargeNow Program.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/evgo-bmw-i3","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:53.783Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_9ad2f78c5d89b864","claim":"Circle Marketing's portfolio page lists website design and development, social media marketing, email marketing, and marketing consultation for Mwokaji Cakery. The page says the website and email marketing phase is still being finished and that results are not yet available.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Mwokaji Cakery","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"We are currently finishing up the website and email marketing phase of the project, and will have regular updates to this Case Study as results start coming in.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/mwokaji-cakery","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:55.983Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_c315db6db7bc7ad5","claim":"Circle Marketing provided e-commerce website work, game photography, and video graphics for USC Football. The work helped generate additional income for the website, and its popularity was sustained through two years of NCAA sanctions.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"USC Football","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"The e-commerce website, game photography, and video graphics all reach a very large fan base of loyal fans and alumni, which helps generate additional income for the website. The website graphics and e-commerce solutions have kept the fans happy and engaged with the content, and popularity was sustained even through two years of NCAA sanctions where the school was not eligible for BCS Championship consideration.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/usc-football","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:56.006Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_785247e8fc49f200","claim":"Circle Marketing provided website design for e-commerce, website graphics, motion graphics video, banner display ads, and game photo editing for USC Football.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"USC Football","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"What We Did:\n\nWebsite Design for E-Commerce\n\nWebsite Graphics\n\nMotion Graphics Video\n\nAdvertising: Banner Display Ads\n\nGame Photo Editing","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/usc-football","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:21:56.007Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_4bda28c1e299a579","claim":"Circle Marketing handled publicity for a donation-only event for Yoga Sol. The page says the event received coverage on a KTLA 5 daily news segment, a two-page spread in the Orange County Register, and a write-up in Orange Coast Magazine.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Yoga Sol Studio","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Yoga Sol has also given back recently with a special donation-only event which Circle Marketing helped handle the publicity for. This event received media attention from a daily news segment on KTLA 5, a two-page spead in the Orange County Register, and a write-up in Orange Coast Magazine.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/yoga-sol-studio","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:05.745Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_53c9d5403ea51f18","claim":"Circle Marketing provided Rule Entertainment with marketing consultation, marketing materials, websites, video production and editing, and event-production support. A marketing, advertising, and publicity plan helped bring over 200 attendees to the first event and about the same number to the second.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Rule Entertainment","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Needing a full marketing package, Circle Marketing worked with Adrian and her team to help create all marketing materials, provide marketing consultation, and also help produce the first couple events. We provided almost every single one of our services to help out Rule Entertainment, which included websites for both Adrian rule the author, as well as her 4 Hour Film Festival brand. In addition, we produced and edited a few videos and dozens of advertising and marketing materials.\n\nThe Results\n\nBeing a new brand and business, the challenge was getting a large enough attendance for the first couple shows with zero brand recognition. Circle Marketing helped create a multi-layered marketing, advertising and publicity plan, which resulted in over 200 attendees at the first event, and about the same at the second.","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/rule-entertainment","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:05.737Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"},{"id":"c_a56a8d49bffb35c1","claim":"John W. said Circle Marketing helped improve the business in every area where it was involved.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":[],"client_name":"Krav Maga Alliance","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"\"Circle Marketing proved to be the missing element in our business strategy. They have helped us improve in every area where they have been involved!\"","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/alliance-krav-maga","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:10.531Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z"}],"validation_limit":"Use as a caveated candidate only: no independent source documents this vendor's work.","independent_work_validation":{"independent_work_claims":0,"work_claims":28,"share":0,"gate_share":0.333,"meets_gate":false},"has_any_independent_validation":false,"claims_on_file":29,"claims_on_file_note":"claims_on_file counts unique ledger claims. A case published on two pages (an agency press release and its case page) is two claims here and is listed once in claims, with also_at.","case_repeats":0,"excluded_other_company_claims":[],"claims_listed":20,"claims_truncated":true,"listed_counts":{"in_ledger":20,"work_claims":20,"independent":0,"independent_work_claims":0}},"alternatives":{"comparison_hints":[],"vendor_slugs":[]},"citation":{"recommendation_readiness":"candidate_only_with_caveat","preferred_sources":[{"source_url":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=3924875226527393134","source_label":"Google","provenance":"third_party","verification_status":"verified","supports":["proof","reputation"],"cited_claims":["Source reference: google.com"]},{"source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","reputation","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Moggy Foggy reports that its social media fan base grew by 15x with Circle Marketing’s efforts.","A testimonial from a client identified as Ray L. says their website ranked #1 on Google and revenue increased 38.5%.","Yoga Sol Studio reports steadily increasing revenue each month, up 92%, and an email list of over two thousand after working with Circle Marketing from pre-launch."]},{"source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/ray-lozano","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","reputation","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Circle Marketing provided Ray Lozano with marketing services, and he reported that his website ranked #1 on search engines and revenue increased 38.5%.","Circle Marketing provided Ray Lozano with SEO, email marketing, social media marketing, and ongoing marketing consultation. The page reports that his site appeared on the first page of search engines for many targeted keywords, with a monthly retainer relationship."]},{"source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/shade-55","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Circle Marketing worked with Shade 55 on its website, social media, email marketing, and marketing collateral. The company helped grow Shade 55's Facebook Likes by over 250%, established a strategy for rewarding email-list sign-ups, and created a Summer 2013 Look Book that was presented to a major retail chain where Shade 55 is now sold nationally."]},{"source_url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/evgo-bmw-i3","source_label":"circlemarketing.com","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Circle Marketing ran a social media advertising campaign for EVgo that generated thousands of likes and sign-ups for its ChargeNow Program.","For EVgo’s BMW i3 ChargeNow Program promotion, Circle Marketing created targeted advertising campaigns on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, using custom audiences, lead generation lists, lookalike audiences, and interest targeting.","The EVgo program ran for 2 months and was repeated as a “last chance” promotion a few quarters later."]}],"required_caveats":["None of the 28 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","Only one third-party evidence claim is normalized."],"do_not_infer":["Do not infer headquarters from service-area coverage.","Do not treat paid visibility as organic ranking proof.","Do not present a source-thin profile as independently verified."]},"quality":{"profile_status":"collected","verification_status":"unverified","needs_review":false,"data_completeness_pct":57,"stale_after":"2027-02-03T15:22:51.803Z","profile_fields_checked_at":null,"claims_rechecked_at":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z","stale":false,"stale_note":null,"profile_status_note":"collected by the crawler, not yet reviewed by an editor","consistency":{"version":"2026.11-profile-consistency","ok":true,"issues":[]},"standard":{"version":"2026.10-profile-standard","open_items":[{"check":"Price signal disclosed","detail":"not disclosed; asked in Before you sign","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"Three strongest proofs name a client and a measured, dated result","detail":"2 of 3","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"Every claim has an observation date","detail":"28 of 29","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"At least a third of documented work comes from independent sources","detail":"0 of 28 work claims","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"Founding year, team size and headquarters on file","detail":"founding year missing, team size missing","closed_by":"collector"}]}},"participation_disclosure":{"paid_visibility":false,"status":"none","package":null,"scoring_note":"Paid visibility is disclosed and never treated as quality evidence."},"source_map":{"human_profile":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/circle-marketing","machine_profile_json":"https://www.pruvado.com/ai/vendors/circle-marketing","vendor_website":"https://circlemarketing.com/","evidence_urls":["https://www.google.com/maps?cid=3924875226527393134","https://circlemarketing.com/","https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/ray-lozano","https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/shade-55","https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/evgo-bmw-i3"]},"model_version":"Evidence-weighted ranking 2026.11.9","generated_at":"2026-11-22T12:18:06.959Z","verification":{"status":"unverified","profile_fields_checked_at":null,"claims_rechecked":{"from":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z","to":"2026-11-05T15:22:51.709Z","claims":28,"of_claims_on_file":29,"label":"Claims re-checked against their source pages Nov 5, 2026"},"stale_after":"2027-02-03T15:22:51.803Z","stale":false,"stale_note":null,"note":"profile_fields_checked_at is when the company and pricing fields were last checked against their sources; claims_rechecked is when the collector last compared each claim's quote with its source page. Neither is a verification by Pruvado unless status is verified."},"company":{"founded":{"value":null,"status":"unknown","source":null,"sources":[],"conflict":false},"team_size":{"value":null,"status":"unknown","source":null,"label":null,"stated_by_source":null},"headquarters":{"value":"Los Angeles, CA, USA","status":"disclosed","source":"profile"},"address":null,"phone":null,"service_regions":["Los Angeles","CA","USA"],"services":[{"category":"Marketing","subcategories":["SEO"]}],"industries":["Small Business"],"client_types":["small_business","entertainment"],"client_types_labels":[{"value":"small_business","label":"Small businesses"},{"value":"entertainment","label":"Entertainment"}],"languages":[],"technologies":[],"certifications":[],"awards":[],"recognitions":[],"named_clients":["EVgo","Mobile Growth Fellowship","Ray Lozano","Krav Maga Alliance","Veterinary Medical Center","ROZANA, Blue Veil Events and Public Relations","Moggy Foggy","Prevention Plus"],"reputation_sources":[{"label":"Google","url":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=3924875226527393134","rating":5,"count":9,"counted":false,"note":"too few reviews to count"}],"process":{"workflow":[],"onboarding":[],"reporting":null,"reporting_label":null},"provenance_note":"Company fields come from the vendor profile; only fields with status verified were checked by Pruvado."},"agency_stated":null,"best_position":{"need":"Small Business","city":"Los Angeles","rank":10,"ranked_total":10,"score_out_of_100":31,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/los-angeles/small-business","score_components":[{"key":"evidence","label":"Evidence for this query","weight":30,"points":6,"value":0.2,"facts":["1 small business claim in the score: 0 third-party, 1 first-party; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Rozana said her company sought marketing and social media direction and that Circle Marketing’s online course gave her resources and tools… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)"]},{"key":"fit","label":"Fit to this query","weight":25,"points":19,"value":0.76,"facts":["Headquartered in Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)","Pricing not disclosed","Profile names small business clients"]},{"key":"capability","label":"Capability depth","weight":15,"points":8.1,"value":0.54,"facts":["1 of 1 listed services are SEO services","1 of 29 claims on file name small business; the score counts 1 of 30 claims and Pruvado profile fields"]},{"key":"reliability","label":"Reliability","weight":10,"points":3,"value":0.3,"facts":["Founding year not disclosed","Retention not documented"]},{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","weight":10,"points":0,"value":0,"facts":["Pricing not disclosed","Team size not disclosed","Process not documented"]},{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","weight":5,"points":0,"value":0,"facts":["No review platform with 10 or more reviews on file","Too few reviews to count (under 10): Google"]},{"key":"credibility","label":"Market credibility","weight":5,"points":0,"value":0,"facts":["No awards, certifications or media mentions with a source on file"]}],"penalties":[{"code":"no_independent_source","label":"No independent source on file","points":-3,"reason":"No independent source describes small business work by this agency; its own published cases do not lift this."},{"code":"profile_not_decision_ready","label":"Profile below decision-ready status","points":-2,"reason":"the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."}]},"positions":[{"need":"Small Business","need_slug":"small-business","city":"Los Angeles","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for small businesses in Los Angeles?","rank":10,"ranked_total":10,"score_out_of_100":31,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/los-angeles/small-business","why_this_rank":["1 small business claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Rozana said her company sought marketing and social media direction and that Circle Marketing’s online course gave her resources and tools… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Headquartered in Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes small business work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes small business work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":5000,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":6,"ranked":10},"neighbors":[{"slug":"seo-optimizers","name":"SEO Optimizers","rank":8,"score_out_of_100":39,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","evidence_basis":"own_published","third_party_claims_for_need":0,"documented_claims_for_need":0,"independent_cases":0,"pricing_display":null,"verified":false,"profile_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/seo-optimizers"},{"slug":"imprint","name":"IMPRiNT","rank":9,"score_out_of_100":34,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","evidence_basis":"own_published","third_party_claims_for_need":0,"documented_claims_for_need":0,"independent_cases":0,"pricing_display":"From $6,500/month","verified":false,"profile_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/imprint"}]},{"need":"SEO for Marketplaces","need_slug":"marketplaces","city":"Los Angeles","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for marketplaces and large listing sites in Los Angeles?","rank":22,"ranked_total":22,"score_out_of_100":28,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/los-angeles/marketplaces","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for marketplaces claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Headquartered in Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":3000,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":14,"ranked":22},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"Local SEO","need_slug":"local-seo","city":"Los Angeles","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented local-search work for businesses in Los Angeles?","rank":26,"ranked_total":28,"score_out_of_100":33,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/los-angeles/local-seo","why_this_rank":["1 local SEO claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing provided Krav Maga Alliance and Alliance Culver City with a monthly full-service marketing retainer covering website… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Headquartered in Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes local SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes local SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":17,"ranked":28},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Lead Generation","need_slug":"lead-generation","city":"Los Angeles","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented lead generation from organic search for businesses in Los Angeles?","rank":59,"ranked_total":61,"score_out_of_100":30,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/los-angeles/lead-generation","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for lead generation claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","For EVgo’s BMW i3 ChargeNow Program promotion, Circle Marketing created targeted advertising campaigns on Facebook, Twitter, and… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Headquartered in Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for lead generation work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for lead generation work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2550,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":31,"ranked":61},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for High-Ticket Services","need_slug":"high-ticket","city":"Los Angeles","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for high-value service businesses in Los Angeles?","rank":61,"ranked_total":61,"score_out_of_100":28,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/los-angeles/high-ticket","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for high-ticket services claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing created an optimized, mobile-compatible website for Veterinary Medical Center that lets prospective patients and clients… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Headquartered in Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for high-ticket services work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for high-ticket services work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":34,"ranked":61},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Marketplaces","need_slug":"marketplaces","city":"Phoenix","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for marketplaces and large listing sites in Phoenix?","rank":102,"ranked_total":104,"score_out_of_100":19,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/marketplaces","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for marketplaces claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Serves Phoenix from Los Angeles, CA, USA; no local office on file","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":37,"ranked":104},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Marketplaces","need_slug":"marketplaces","city":"San Francisco","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for marketplaces and large listing sites in San Francisco?","rank":102,"ranked_total":104,"score_out_of_100":19,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/san-francisco/marketplaces","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for marketplaces claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Serves San Francisco from Los Angeles, CA, USA; no local office on file","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":37,"ranked":104},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Marketplaces","need_slug":"marketplaces","city":"Atlanta","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for marketplaces and large listing sites in Atlanta?","rank":103,"ranked_total":104,"score_out_of_100":19,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/atlanta/marketplaces","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for marketplaces claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Serves Atlanta from Los Angeles, CA, USA; no local office on file","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":37,"ranked":104},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"Small Business","need_slug":"small-business","city":"San Francisco","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for small businesses in San Francisco?","rank":16,"ranked_total":16,"score_out_of_100":22,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":false,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/san-francisco/small-business","why_this_rank":["1 small business claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Rozana said her company sought marketing and social media direction and that Circle Marketing’s online course gave her resources and tools… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Serves San Francisco from Los Angeles, CA, USA; no local office on file","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes small business work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes small business work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":4000,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":7,"ranked":16},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Marketplaces","need_slug":"marketplaces","city":"Chicago","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for marketplaces and large listing sites in Chicago?","rank":102,"ranked_total":104,"score_out_of_100":19,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":false,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/chicago/marketplaces","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for marketplaces claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Serves Chicago from Los Angeles, CA, USA; no local office on file","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":37,"ranked":104},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Marketplaces","need_slug":"marketplaces","city":"Seattle","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for marketplaces and large listing sites in Seattle?","rank":102,"ranked_total":104,"score_out_of_100":19,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":false,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/seattle/marketplaces","why_this_rank":["1 SEO for marketplaces claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Circle Marketing reports overall increases in traffic, conversions, and SEO listings, with AdWords click-through rates increasing, social… (circlemarketing.com, claimed)","Serves Seattle from Los Angeles, CA, USA; no local office on file","Pricing not disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Pricing not disclosed; budget fit cannot be checked before outreach.","Never verified against official sources.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for marketplaces work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","points":0,"max":10},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":30,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":29},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":37,"ranked":104},"neighbors":[]}],"client_voice":{"observed_at":"2026-11-06T13:54:39.345Z","sample_share_read":null,"review_drive_caution":null,"platforms":[{"platform":"Google","url":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=3924875226527393134","rating":5,"reviews":9,"threshold":10,"bbb_grade":null,"complaints_last_3_years":null,"counted":false,"note":"too few reviews to count"}],"average_rating":null,"total_reviews":0,"reviews_on_all_platforms":9,"counting_rule":"average_rating and total_reviews count only platforms with 10 or more reviews; a platform below that is listed with counted false.","reviews_read":3,"sample":{"read":3,"of_total":0,"label":"3 read","read_by_platform":{"google":3,"trustpilot":0},"last_collected_at":"2026-11-06T13:54:39.345Z","collection":"full"},"recency":{"last_12_months":0,"years_1_to_3":0,"older":3,"undated":0,"shares":{"last12m":0,"years1to3":0,"older":1},"line":"0% last 12 months, 0% 1 to 3 years, 100% older"},"last_12_months_share":0,"negative_share":0,"negative_count":0,"negative_rule":"Share of read reviews with a rating of 3 stars or lower, among read reviews that carry a rating.","bbb_complaints":null,"owner_answer_rate":0,"review_burst":null,"summary":"Clients most often value Circle Marketing’s marketing knowledge, hard work, and informative, personal service. Some testimonials report specific gains in rankings, revenue, social media following, and email subscribers. All supplied reviews are positive, though several detailed outcome claims come from testimonials published by the agency.","praised":[{"theme":"Passion and commitment to clients","icon":"other","mentions":2,"quote":"passionate and committed to their clients’ needs.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"theme":"Hard work and honesty","icon":"honesty","mentions":1,"quote":"hard working, honest, get it done kind of business","source":"Google"},{"theme":"Marketing knowledge","icon":"expertise","mentions":1,"quote":"Very knowledgable about the whole marketing process","source":"Google"},{"theme":"Informative communication","icon":"communication","mentions":1,"quote":"always informative!","source":"Google"},{"theme":"Positive experience with the new website","icon":"design","mentions":1,"quote":"It's amazing...Circle Marketing is amazing.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"}],"criticized":[],"results_reported_by_clients":[{"result":"Social media fan base grew 15 times.","quote":"Our social media fan base grew by 15x fold!","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"result":"Website ranked number one on Google and revenue increased 38.5%.","quote":"My website is ranked #1 on Google, and revenue has increased 38.5%!","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"result":"Revenue increased 92% and the email list grew to over two thousand.","quote":"we have steadily increased revenue each month (up 92%), and have grown an email list over two thousand.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"result":"Website ranked number one on search engines, customers could locate the business easily, and revenue increased 38.5%.","quote":"My website is ranked #1 on search engines, and costumers locate me easily. I keep detailed records of my books, and revenue has increased 38.5%!","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"}],"hired_for":[{"service":"Website and search engine visibility","mentions":2,"icon":"seo"},{"service":"Marketing support","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"service":"Marketing services","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"service":"Social media growth","mentions":1,"icon":"social"},{"service":"Marketing from pre-launch","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"service":"New website","mentions":1,"icon":"web"}],"client_types":[{"type":"General business","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"type":"Prevention and wellness business","mentions":1,"icon":"healthcare"},{"type":"Yoga studio","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"type":"Martial arts organization","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"type":"Events business","mentions":1,"icon":"other"},{"type":"Events and public relations company","mentions":1,"icon":"other"}],"named_testimonials":[{"client":"Moggy Foggy","quote":"Our social media fan base grew by 15x fold! If you're looking for a team that'll show as much passion for your business as you, call Circle Marketing!","url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":false},{"client":"Prevention Plus","quote":"\"My website is ranked #1 on Google, and revenue has increased 38.5%!\"\nRay L.\nPrevention Plus","url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":false},{"client":"Yoga Sol Studio","quote":"\"Working with Circle Marketing from pre-launch, we have steadily increased revenue each month (up 92%), and have grown an email list over two thousand.\"\nRozanne E.\nYoga Sol Studio","url":"https://circlemarketing.com/","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true},{"client":"Ray Lozano","quote":"\"I know very little about marketing. I just want to do my work, and have people find me. Circle Marketing has done such an amazing job, I keep them on retainer. My website is ranked #1 on search engines, and costumers locate me easily. I keep detailed records of my books, and revenue has increased 38.5%!\"","url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/ray-lozano","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true},{"client":"Krav Maga Alliance","quote":"\"Circle Marketing proved to be the missing element in our business strategy. They have helped us improve in every area where they have been involved!\"","url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/alliance-krav-maga","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true},{"client":"Tiaras and Tacones Events","quote":"\"I can't describe my happiness!! I am so full of energy right now just looking at my new site! It's amazing...Circle Marketing is amazing. :)\"","url":"https://circlemarketing.com/portfolio/tiaras-tacones-events","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true}],"note":"Ratings and reviews from independent platforms; quotes are verbatim and checked against the review text. Testimonials published by the agency are labelled as such."}}