{"schema_version":"vendar.ai.vendor-summary.v1","object_type":"vendor_decision_summary","canonical_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/blacksmith-agency","machine_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/ai/vendors/blacksmith-agency","last_updated_at":"2026-11-05T11:11:48.003Z","vendor":{"slug":"blacksmith-agency","name":"Blacksmith Agency","website":"https://blacksmith.agency/","one_line":"Phoenix web design and development studio that also runs SEO for its builds.","company_type":"agency","headquarters_location":"Phoenix, AZ, USA","service_regions":["Phoenix","Arizona","USA"],"primary_services":["SEO"],"services_in_evidence":[{"service":"Web design","work_claims":23},{"service":"SEO","work_claims":13},{"service":"PPC","work_claims":13}],"services_in_evidence_note":"Each of the 66 work examples on file counted once per service it names; one example can name several services, so the counts can add up to more than 66."},"decision":{"verdict":{"label":"Ranked","summary":"Admitted to a ranking on documented work, outside the top three for every question it appears in. None of its 66 work examples comes from an independent source.","note":"Lower profile confidence; the profile is not verified by Pruvado.","missing_for_recommended":[]},"score_out_of_100":48,"confidence":{"label":"Lower confidence","score":0.62,"capped_reason":"Rated from the evidence on file (sources, independence, confirmed quotes), not by an editor.","source":"evidence","scope":"profile","score_note":null},"best_for":["Your business matches the client types on file (enterprises, startups) and the industries on file (saas, healthcare, education).","You need what reviewers hired it for: Website rebuild (1 of 2 mentions); PPC program (1)."],"not_for":["You need the minimum term and setup fee in writing before you commit: neither is published."],"risks":["None of the 66 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","9 of 9 results with a number do not say what year they were measured.","Few outside reviews mention Technical SEO work specifically."],"open_questions":["Ask for the minimum term, setup fee: not published.","Ask for a Technical SEO case close to your business, with the result and the year it was measured.","Ask for two client references you can call: no independent case of Technical SEO work on file."],"not_published":["minimum monthly budget","typical range","minimum term","setup fee"],"claim_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/blacksmith-agency/claim","claim_note":"Agencies can state commercial terms here; published fields are labelled agency_stated.","score_basis":"Score of its best position: #6 Technical SEO, Phoenix","profile_scores":{"version":"2026.11-profile-scores","completeness":{"data_completeness_pct":67,"label":"Data completeness, separate from the ranking score","parts":[{"key":"identity","label":"Who the company is: website, headquarters, founding year, team size, logo, regions served","points":20,"max":20,"detail":"complete"},{"key":"fit","label":"Fit: services, industries, client types","points":15,"max":15,"detail":"complete"},{"key":"commercial","label":"Commercial terms: model, entry price, hourly rate, minimum term, setup fee","points":10,"max":20,"detail":"model, minimum term, setup fee"},{"key":"work","label":"Documented work: cases naming a client and a result (target 5) and work examples overall (target 10)","points":22,"max":30,"detail":"3 cases with a named client and a result, 66 work claims"},{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation: rating and review count on two or more platforms, each with 10 or more reviews","points":0,"max":15,"detail":"0 platforms with a rating and 10 or more reviews"}]},"trust":{"trust_score_out_of_100":70,"label":"Trust score, separate from the ranking score","parts":[{"key":"independence","label":"Who is speaking: independent sources among work examples (full marks at 40%)","points":0,"max":30,"detail":"0 of 66 work claims are independent"},{"key":"checked","label":"Checked against the source page: confirmed, or half for partly confirmed","points":25,"max":25,"detail":"60 confirmed, 0 partly, of 60 with a source"},{"key":"quoted_numbers","label":"Numbers backed by a verbatim quote from the source","points":20,"max":20,"detail":"3 of 3"},{"key":"fresh","label":"Seen within the last 365 days","points":15,"max":15,"detail":"60 of 60"},{"key":"not_contradicted","label":"Not contradicted: claims their source no longer supports","points":10,"max":10,"detail":"0 not supported by their page"}]}},"fit_source":{"best_for":"derived","not_for":"derived"}},"pricing":{"display":"Projects from $50,000","model":null,"minimum_monthly_budget_usd":null,"minimum_project_size_usd":50000,"pricing_range_min_usd":null,"pricing_range_max_usd":null,"hourly_rate_range":"$150 - $199","public_summary":null,"secondary_options":[],"pricing_known":true,"display_basis":"published by the agency","setup_fee_usd":null,"contract_min_months":null,"engagement_models":[],"engagement_models_labels":[],"model_label":null,"minimum_project_note":null,"band_note":null,"status":"disclosed","not_disclosed":["minimum monthly budget","typical range","minimum term","setup fee"],"agency_stated_fields":[],"published_on_site_on":null,"packages":[],"published_sources":[],"earlier_values":[]},"evidence":{"posture":{"label":"thin","summary":"No independent source documents this vendor's work; treat it as a candidate only."},"independent_validation_scope":"none","independent_validation_label":"First-party evidence only","independence_statement":"None of the 66 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","source_counts":{"definition":"Each claim on file counted once by who wrote it. Only 'independent' counts as outside proof.","total":66,"by_speaker":{"independent":0,"affiliated":0,"vendor_controlled":0,"vendor":66},"work_claims":66,"independent_work_claims":0,"independent_work_share":0,"unique_urls":20,"scope":"whole_ledger","scope_note":"Counted over every claim in the ledger (claims_on_file), not over the claims array, which lists at most 20."},"claims":[{"id":"c_804c429d41ec2a15","claim":"Blacksmith rebuilt Montium's website and PPC program with property-by-property campaigns and hyperlocal targeting, delivering 10x more leads at 87% lower cost per lead.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["lead-generation"],"client_name":"Montium","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Blacksmith rebuilt the website and PPC program from scratch, with property-by-property campaigns and hyperlocal targeting that delivered 10x more leads at 87% lower cost.","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:00:46.515Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T13:03:55.379Z"},{"id":"c_bd39e34634424ffe","claim":"For Tianma, Blacksmith restructured product pages and improved site speed. The work cut load times by 86.67%.","claim_type":"case_study","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["technical-seo","ecommerce"],"client_name":"Tianma","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Through advanced caching, code minification, and improved content delivery, we cut load times by 86.67%, making the site feel instant.","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/services/branding-agency/b2b-branding","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:15.662Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_58695c95da66e3cd","claim":"The page lists a case study titled 'Voss Water SEO Case Study', documenting SEO work for client Voss Water.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Voss Water","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Voss Water SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/cpg","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:01:57.130Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T13:03:55.379Z"},{"id":"c_1dafe4d5381543ad","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists an SEO case study for Crummer Rollins College in the education industry. The page does not state any results from the engagement.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Crummer Rollins College","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Crummer Rollins College SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/education","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:02:51.781Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T13:03:55.379Z"},{"id":"c_261c73a7d64fc06f","claim":"The page lists a Crummer Rollins College SEO case study among Blacksmith's documented work.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Crummer Rollins College","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Crummer Rollins College SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:00:46.541Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T20:47:50.623Z"},{"id":"c_04f081204ae52748","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study for client Coastal Community Bank covering SEO work in the finance industry.","claim_type":"case_study","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Coastal Community Bank","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Coastal Community Bank SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/finance","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:02:30.797Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T20:47:50.623Z"},{"id":"c_65c78643e571a97b","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study for client Laitek covering SEO work in the healthcare industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket","by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Laitek","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Laitek SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:20.883Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_7a80e9ffe99833b7","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study for client JSI covering SEO work in the telecommunications industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"JSI","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"JSI SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:20.885Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_687da9fcd64fe9a4","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study titled 'JSI SEO Case Study', categorized as SEO / Telecommunications. The page excerpt provides no details on the work performed or results achieved.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"JSI","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"JSI SEO Case Study ... SEO / Telecommunications","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/seo","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:39.946Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_486465909c3b4a18","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study titled 'Cision SEO Case Study', categorized as SEO / Public Relations. The page excerpt provides no details on the work performed or results achieved.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Cision","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Cision SEO Case Study ... SEO / Public Relations","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/seo","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:39.948Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_1d2236bfc92ed217","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study titled 'Coaching Right Now SEO Case Study', categorized as SEO / Professional Development. The page excerpt provides no details on the work performed or results achieved.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Coaching Right Now","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Coaching Right Now SEO Case Study ... SEO / Professional Development","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/seo","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:39.957Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_d6ead28b222846f3","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study titled 'Bonanno Concepts SEO Case Study', categorized as SEO / Hospitality. The page excerpt provides no details on the work performed or results achieved.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Bonanno Concepts","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Bonanno Concepts SEO Case Study ... SEO / Hospitality","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/seo","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:39.961Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_447a6b9465a3f55c","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study titled 'Clear Marketing SEO Case Study', categorized as SEO / Finance. The page excerpt provides no details on the work performed or results achieved.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Clear Marketing","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Clear Marketing SEO Case Study ... SEO / Finance","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/seo","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:39.964Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_420ee83dab1aa9f5","claim":"The page lists an Aptive Resources SEO case study in the Government industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["by-budget","retainer","in-house-team"],"client_name":"Aptive Resources","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Aptive Resources SEO Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/government","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-05T11:11:44.655Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-05T11:11:48.003Z"},{"id":"c_56df4857299c6c2f","claim":"Blacksmith Agency documents a web design case study for a client named NYCLA in the legal industry. The page excerpt does not state the scope of the work, any results, or the time period.","claim_type":"case_study","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"NYCLA","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"NYCLA Web Design Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/legal","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:02:03.466Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T13:03:55.379Z"},{"id":"c_1554b0c667d3e65e","claim":"Cayla Cook, Marketing & Communications Manager at Medical Education & Research Institute, said Blacksmith Agency made design suggestions, stayed on time and budget, and communicated regularly.","claim_type":"client_review","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"Medical Education & Research Institute","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Blacksmith Agency has listened to us every step of the way and made design suggestions that make sense. They’re on time and budget and communicate regularly.","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:00:46.527Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T20:47:50.623Z"},{"id":"c_bccccd3f6d452b27","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a branding case study for client Laitek in the healthcare industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"Laitek","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Laitek Branding Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/branding","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:02:20.336Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T20:47:50.623Z"},{"id":"c_e6d0c633333c80eb","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a web design case study for Laitek in the healthcare industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"Laitek","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Laitek Web Design Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/web-design","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-01T13:02:41.576Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-01T20:47:50.623Z"},{"id":"c_b40e3c1b8454fdd3","claim":"Blacksmith lists a web design case study for Laitek in the healthcare industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"Laitek","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Laitek Web Design Case Study Web Design / Healthcare","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/services/web-design/ecommerce","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:08.975Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"},{"id":"c_1964bab14b874359","claim":"Blacksmith Agency lists a case study for client Laitek covering web development work in the healthcare industry.","claim_type":"portfolio_project","describes_work":true,"in_ledger":true,"speaker":"vendor","counts_as_independent_work":false,"needs":["high-ticket"],"client_name":"Laitek","result_period":null,"measured_result":false,"quote":"Laitek Web Development Case Study","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies","also_at":[],"provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","check_status":"confirmed","observed_at":"2026-11-02T10:46:20.884Z","last_checked_at":"2026-11-02T10:47:54.543Z"}],"validation_limit":"Use as a caveated candidate only: no independent source documents this vendor's work.","independent_work_validation":{"independent_work_claims":0,"work_claims":66,"share":0,"gate_share":0.333,"meets_gate":false},"has_any_independent_validation":false,"claims_on_file":66,"claims_on_file_note":"claims_on_file counts unique ledger claims. A case published on two pages (an agency press release and its case page) is two claims here and is listed once in claims, with also_at.","case_repeats":6,"excluded_other_company_claims":[],"claims_listed":20,"claims_truncated":true,"listed_counts":{"in_ledger":20,"work_claims":20,"independent":0,"independent_work_claims":0}},"alternatives":{"comparison_hints":[],"vendor_slugs":[]},"citation":{"recommendation_readiness":"candidate_only_with_caveat","preferred_sources":[{"source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","reputation","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Blacksmith rebuilt Montium's website and PPC program with property-by-property campaigns and hyperlocal targeting, delivering 10x more leads at 87% lower cost per lead.","John Schwarberg, Director Web Strategy & Optimization at Cision, said the team never missed deadlines, was often ahead of schedule, and made Cision feel like a true partner.","Cayla Cook, Marketing & Communications Manager at Medical Education & Research Institute, said Blacksmith Agency made design suggestions, stayed on time and budget, and communicated regularly."]},{"source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/ppc","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Blacksmith Agency lists a PPC case study for client CBS Rentals, categorized under PPC / AEC.","Blacksmith Agency lists a PPC case study for client Crummer Rollins College, categorized under PPC / Education.","Blacksmith Agency lists a PPC case study for client Cision, categorized under PPC / Public Relations."]},{"source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/aec","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","reputation","source_map"],"cited_claims":["Blacksmith Agency lists a web design case study for client FORM Architects. The page excerpt does not state the project's results.","Blacksmith Agency lists a web design case study for client Bragg Companies. The page excerpt does not state the project's results.","Blacksmith Agency lists a PPC case study for client CBS Rentals, categorized as PPC / AEC. The page excerpt does not state the services' results."]},{"source_url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/cpg","source_label":"blacksmith.agency","provenance":"first_party","verification_status":"claimed","supports":["proof","reputation","source_map"],"cited_claims":["The page lists a case study titled 'Voss Water SEO Case Study', documenting SEO work for client Voss Water.","The page lists a case study titled 'Voss Water Web Development Case Study', documenting web development work for client Voss Water.","The page lists a case study titled 'Voss Water PPC Case Study', documenting PPC work for client Voss Water."]}],"required_caveats":["None of the 66 documented work examples comes from an independent source; all are the agency's own account or sources it controls.","Only one third-party evidence claim is normalized."],"do_not_infer":["Do not infer headquarters from service-area coverage.","Do not treat paid visibility as organic ranking proof.","Do not present a source-thin profile as independently verified."]},"quality":{"profile_status":"collected","verification_status":"unverified","needs_review":false,"data_completeness_pct":67,"stale_after":"2027-02-03T11:11:48.088Z","profile_fields_checked_at":"2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z","claims_rechecked_at":"2026-11-05T11:11:48.003Z","stale":false,"stale_note":null,"profile_status_note":"collected by the crawler, not yet reviewed by an editor","consistency":{"version":"2026.11-profile-consistency","ok":true,"issues":[]},"standard":{"version":"2026.10-profile-standard","open_items":[{"check":"Three strongest proofs name a client and a measured, dated result","detail":"0 of 3","closed_by":"collector"},{"check":"At least a third of documented work comes from independent sources","detail":"0 of 66 work claims","closed_by":"collector"}]}},"participation_disclosure":{"paid_visibility":false,"status":"none","package":null,"scoring_note":"Paid visibility is disclosed and never treated as quality evidence."},"source_map":{"human_profile":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/blacksmith-agency","machine_profile_json":"https://www.pruvado.com/ai/vendors/blacksmith-agency","vendor_website":"https://blacksmith.agency/","evidence_urls":["https://blacksmith.agency/","https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/service/ppc","https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/aec","https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/cpg"]},"model_version":"Evidence-weighted ranking 2026.11.9","generated_at":"2026-11-22T12:17:51.814Z","verification":{"status":"unverified","profile_fields_checked_at":"2026-09-23T00:00:00.000Z","claims_rechecked":{"from":"2026-11-01T13:03:55.379Z","to":"2026-11-05T11:11:48.003Z","claims":66,"of_claims_on_file":66,"label":"Claims re-checked against their source pages Nov 1 to Nov 5, 2026"},"stale_after":"2027-02-03T11:11:48.088Z","stale":false,"stale_note":null,"note":"profile_fields_checked_at is when the company and pricing fields were last checked against their sources; claims_rechecked is when the collector last compared each claim's quote with its source page. Neither is a verification by Pruvado unless status is verified."},"company":{"founded":{"value":2012,"status":"disclosed","source":"profile","sources":[],"conflict":false},"team_size":{"value":"10 to 49","status":"disclosed","source":"profile","label":"10 to 49 people","stated_by_source":null},"headquarters":{"value":"Phoenix, AZ, USA","status":"disclosed","source":"profile"},"address":null,"phone":null,"service_regions":["Phoenix","Arizona","USA"],"services":[{"category":"Marketing","subcategories":["SEO"]}],"industries":["SaaS","Healthcare","Education","Retail","Manufacturing","Construction","Finance","Hospitality"],"client_types":["enterprise","startup"],"client_types_labels":[{"value":"enterprise","label":"Enterprises"},{"value":"startup","label":"Startups"}],"languages":["English"],"technologies":[],"certifications":[],"awards":[],"recognitions":[],"named_clients":["Montium","Tianma","Voss Water","NYCLA","Crummer Rollins College","Medical Education & Research Institute","Laitek","Coastal Community Bank"],"reputation_sources":[],"process":{"workflow":[],"onboarding":[],"reporting":null,"reporting_label":null},"provenance_note":"Company fields come from the vendor profile; only fields with status verified were checked by Pruvado."},"agency_stated":null,"best_position":{"need":"Technical SEO","city":"Phoenix","rank":6,"ranked_total":19,"score_out_of_100":48,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/technical-seo","score_components":[{"key":"evidence","label":"Evidence for this query","weight":30,"points":8,"value":0.267,"facts":["1 technical SEO claim in the score: 0 third-party, 1 first-party; outside claims from 1 distinct site","For Tianma, Blacksmith restructured product pages and improved site speed. The work cut load times by 86.67%. (blacksmith.agency, claimed)"]},{"key":"fit","label":"Fit to this query","weight":25,"points":22,"value":0.88,"facts":["Headquartered in Phoenix (Phoenix, AZ, USA)","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed","Profile names enterprise clients"]},{"key":"capability","label":"Capability depth","weight":15,"points":7.8,"value":0.52,"facts":["1 of 1 listed services are SEO services","1 of 66 claims on file name technical SEO; the score counts 1 of 67 claims and Pruvado profile fields"]},{"key":"reliability","label":"Reliability","weight":10,"points":7.2,"value":0.72,"facts":["In business since 2012","Retention not documented"]},{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","weight":10,"points":7.5,"value":0.75,"facts":["Pricing disclosed (Projects from $50,000)","Team size 10 to 49","Process not documented"]},{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","weight":5,"points":0,"value":0,"facts":["No review platform with 10 or more reviews on file"]},{"key":"credibility","label":"Market credibility","weight":5,"points":0,"value":0,"facts":["No awards, certifications or media mentions with a source on file"]}],"penalties":[{"code":"no_independent_source","label":"No independent source on file","points":-3,"reason":"No independent source describes technical SEO work by this agency; its own published cases do not lift this."},{"code":"profile_not_decision_ready","label":"Profile below decision-ready status","points":-2,"reason":"the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."}]},"positions":[{"need":"Technical SEO","need_slug":"technical-seo","city":"Phoenix","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented technical-SEO work for businesses in Phoenix?","rank":6,"ranked_total":19,"score_out_of_100":48,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/technical-seo","why_this_rank":["1 technical SEO claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","For Tianma, Blacksmith restructured product pages and improved site speed. The work cut load times by 86.67%. (blacksmith.agency, claimed)","Headquartered in Phoenix (Phoenix, AZ, USA)","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes technical SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes technical SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","points":0,"max":5},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":67,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":66},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":1448,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":10,"ranked":19},"neighbors":[{"slug":"signa-marketing","name":"Signa Marketing","rank":5,"score_out_of_100":49,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","evidence_basis":"own_published","third_party_claims_for_need":0,"documented_claims_for_need":0,"independent_cases":0,"pricing_display":"Projects from $5,000","verified":false,"profile_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/signa-marketing"},{"slug":"turnkey-website-design","name":"TurnKey Website Design","rank":7,"score_out_of_100":46,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","evidence_basis":"own_published","third_party_claims_for_need":0,"documented_claims_for_need":0,"independent_cases":0,"pricing_display":"From $1,400/month","verified":false,"profile_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/vendors/turnkey-website-design"}]},{"need":"Ecommerce SEO","need_slug":"ecommerce","city":"Phoenix","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented ecommerce-SEO work for businesses in Phoenix?","rank":6,"ranked_total":13,"score_out_of_100":44,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/ecommerce","why_this_rank":["1 ecommerce SEO claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","For Tianma, Blacksmith restructured product pages and improved site speed. The work cut load times by 86.67%. (blacksmith.agency, claimed)","Headquartered in Phoenix (Phoenix, AZ, USA)","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes ecommerce SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes ecommerce SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","points":0,"max":5},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":67,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":66},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":1500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":5,"ranked":13},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO Agencies with an In-house Team","need_slug":"in-house-team","city":"Phoenix","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies in Phoenix with documented work have an in-house team of ten or more?","rank":9,"ranked_total":14,"score_out_of_100":53,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/in-house-team","why_this_rank":["Score of its best documented need in Phoenix: SEO for Lead Generation, #10 of 54.","6 SEO for lead generation claims on file: 0 third-party, 6 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Blacksmith rebuilt Montium's website and PPC program with property-by-property campaigns and hyperlocal targeting, delivering 10x more… (blacksmith.agency, claimed)","Headquartered in Phoenix (Phoenix, AZ, USA)","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for lead generation work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for lead generation work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","points":0,"max":5},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":67,"on_file_naming_this_need":12,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":66},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2000,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":11,"ranked":14},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for Lead Generation","need_slug":"lead-generation","city":"Phoenix","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented lead generation from organic search for businesses in Phoenix?","rank":10,"ranked_total":54,"score_out_of_100":53,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/lead-generation","why_this_rank":["6 SEO for lead generation claims on file: 0 third-party, 6 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Blacksmith rebuilt Montium's website and PPC program with property-by-property campaigns and hyperlocal targeting, delivering 10x more… (blacksmith.agency, claimed)","Headquartered in Phoenix (Phoenix, AZ, USA)","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for lead generation work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for lead generation work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","points":0,"max":5},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":67,"on_file_naming_this_need":6,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":66},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":500,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":15,"ranked":54},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"SEO for High-Ticket Services","need_slug":"high-ticket","city":"Phoenix","city_relation":"own","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented SEO work for high-value service businesses in Phoenix?","rank":12,"ranked_total":43,"score_out_of_100":50,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/phoenix/high-ticket","why_this_rank":["7 SEO for high-ticket services claims on file: 0 third-party, 7 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","Blacksmith Agency documents a web design case study for a client named NYCLA in the legal industry. The page excerpt does not state the… (blacksmith.agency, claimed)","Headquartered in Phoenix (Phoenix, AZ, USA)","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes SEO for high-ticket services work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes SEO for high-ticket services work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","points":0,"max":5},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":67,"on_file_naming_this_need":7,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":66},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":1495,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":19,"ranked":43},"neighbors":[]},{"need":"Technical SEO","need_slug":"technical-seo","city":"Seattle","city_relation":"other_city","question":"Which SEO agencies have documented technical-SEO work for businesses in Seattle?","rank":70,"ranked_total":192,"score_out_of_100":39,"confidence":"Moderate confidence","confidence_scope":"listing","evidence_basis":"own_published","evidence_basis_label":"Agency's own case studies only","independent_confirmation":{"cases":0,"applied_penalty":-3,"label":"Independent confirmation: none, minus 3 in the score"},"index_open":true,"listing_url":"https://www.pruvado.com/marketing/seo/seattle/technical-seo","why_this_rank":["1 technical SEO claim on file: 0 third-party, 1 first-party, 0 profile signals; outside claims from 1 distinct site","For Tianma, Blacksmith restructured product pages and improved site speed. The work cut load times by 86.67%. (blacksmith.agency, claimed)","Serves Seattle from Phoenix, AZ, USA; no local office on file","Projects from $50,000; no monthly floor disclosed"],"limits":["No independent source describes technical SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","Profile below decision-ready status: the profile is collected but not reviewed yet."],"next_proof_needed":"No independent source describes technical SEO work; the evidence is the agency's own or editorial.","weakest_criterion":{"key":"reputation","label":"Reputation","points":0,"max":5},"claims_for_need":{"documented_work":0,"third_party":0,"claims_and_profile_fields":67,"on_file_naming_this_need":1,"on_file_independent":0,"of_claims_on_file":66},"listed_on_offer_only":false,"listing_pricing":{"pricing_floor_median_usd":2250,"unit":"per month","comparable_with_vendor_price":false,"pricing_known":90,"ranked":192},"neighbors":[]}],"client_voice":{"observed_at":"2026-11-06T13:34:58.844Z","sample_share_read":null,"review_drive_caution":null,"platforms":[],"average_rating":null,"total_reviews":0,"reviews_on_all_platforms":0,"counting_rule":"average_rating and total_reviews count only platforms with 10 or more reviews; a platform below that is listed with counted false.","reviews_read":0,"sample":{"read":0,"of_total":0,"label":null,"read_by_platform":{"google":0,"trustpilot":0},"last_collected_at":"2026-11-06T13:34:58.844Z","collection":"full"},"recency":null,"last_12_months_share":null,"negative_share":null,"negative_count":0,"negative_rule":"Share of read reviews with a rating of 3 stars or lower, among read reviews that carry a rating.","bbb_complaints":null,"owner_answer_rate":null,"review_burst":null,"summary":"Clients most often describe a responsive, collaborative team that listens, communicates, and delivers on schedule and budget. One review reports substantially more leads at lower cost; the available feedback is consistently positive, with no stated criticisms.","praised":[{"theme":"Listening and collaborative partnership","icon":"communication","mentions":3,"quote":"The team listens to our needs, provides sound advice, and reacts appropriately, making us feel like we are a true partner.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"theme":"Responsiveness and regular communication","icon":"communication","mentions":2,"quote":"They’re on time and budget and communicate regularly.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"theme":"Meeting deadlines and schedules","icon":"responsiveness","mentions":2,"quote":"They’ve never missed any deadlines and often are ahead of schedule.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"},{"theme":"Flexible, high-quality work and value","icon":"price","mentions":1,"quote":"they also offered great value for money and high-quality work.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"}],"criticized":[],"results_reported_by_clients":[{"result":"A reported tenfold increase in leads at 87% lower cost.","quote":"delivered 10x more leads at 87% lower cost.","source":"client quoted on the agency's site"}],"hired_for":[{"service":"Website rebuild","mentions":1,"icon":"web"},{"service":"PPC program","mentions":1,"icon":"ppc"}],"client_types":[{"type":"Medical education and research organization","mentions":1,"icon":"healthcare"},{"type":"Automation company","mentions":1,"icon":"other"}],"named_testimonials":[{"client":"Montium","quote":"Blacksmith rebuilt the website and PPC program from scratch, with property-by-property campaigns and hyperlocal targeting that delivered 10x more leads at 87% lower cost.","url":"https://blacksmith.agency/","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":false},{"client":"Cision","quote":"We always feel like we are their highest priority. They’ve never missed any deadlines and often are ahead of schedule. The team listens to our needs, provides sound advice, and reacts appropriately, making us feel like we are a true partner.","url":"https://blacksmith.agency/","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true},{"client":"FORM Architects","quote":"FORM Architects Web Design Case Study","url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/aec","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":false},{"client":"Bragg Companies","quote":"Bragg Companies Web Design Case Study","url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/aec","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":false},{"client":"Voss Water","quote":"Voss Water SEO Case Study","url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/cpg","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true},{"client":"Voss Water","quote":"Voss Water Web Development Case Study","url":"https://blacksmith.agency/case-studies/industry/cpg","published_by":"agency","also_documented_case":true}],"note":"Ratings and reviews from independent platforms; quotes are verbatim and checked against the review text. Testimonials published by the agency are labelled as such."}}